Recently,
the WA Branch of the Australian Nursing Federation felt that it was necessary
to start protesting about the rise of parking costs in many of Perth’s
hospitals and this got me thinking about our health system and standard of
living.
The
ANF and those it represents feel that the increases in what it costs to park
your car in a privately run car park at work is completely outrageous and a
total abomination.
While
it is annoying having to add another mundane item in your weekly budget, I feel
that this campaign shows how lucky we are in Western Australia, where the price
of parking is all a trade union can campaign about.
In
other parts of the world they are not so lucky to have even the most basic
equipment, medicine or trained staff. In many places access to cars to drive to
work or medicines or employees to sit with patients who are confused and
elderly (to ensure their safety) are simply not available.
I
am sure that many nurses and doctors from developing countries would love to
have nothing to protest about except what it costs to park their car.
In
Ghana for example, one story was told of a lady being left to give birth in the
open and without professional nursing assistance. It is common in Ghana for
there not to be any permanent medical and nursing staff at healthcare posts and
limited access to the most basic of medicines and laboratory services.
The
Democratic Republic of Congo is another country where funding the recent civil
war has replaced maintaining the health system and ensuring that its citizens
are healthy enough to lead productive lives.
An
article in Britain’s Financial Times (September 15, 2009) reports that
2006-2007 alone, children accounted for 47% of all those who died, although
they only constitute only 19% of the total population.
I
could go on and write about every country who is unable able, for whatever reason,
to provide a functional healthcare system but I am sure you get the
picture.
It’s
just a little disappointing that those who take part in the protests (and
Australian society in general) don’t take a moment to step back and look at the
bigger picture.
In
same way that when I overheard a visitor tell a patient in hospital where I
work that he thought the WA health system was Third World. I wanted to ask them
if they had actually been to any developing country and on what evidence where
they basing their comparison.
How
could anyone say that a large government owned and operated (for now) hospital
in Western Australia is of “third world standards"?
With 900 million people not having enough money to access to clean drinking water, let alone access to basic medical care (J Braithwaite, date unknown) such as GPs and midwives shows how people in the developing world have to struggle to visit a doctor or vaccinate their children.
The price of medication doesn't help either. Many of the medications available to these people are patented by for-profit companies in the West which makes them more expensive and out of reach for most people living under 2.8 million living under two dollars a day and the millions more living just above that.
I think those in Western Australia are incredibly fortunate to be able to access a hospital system where so much is provided for.
For example, three meals a day are guaranteed to be served; there is a ready supply of clean bed linen; rooms get cleaned everyday; there are physios, occupational therapists, social workers all trying to get patents ready to go home.
There are even welfare assistants to help patients and their families access government benefits (unheard of in developing countries) if you need it as well as contact utility companies if you are in hospital for longer than expected and need help to rearrange payment
You want to see a Chaplain for spiritual support? One will come to see you without questions, fees or charges.
Hardly sounds like a third world system to me but one that we have access to.Working in a hospital in a large Australian city after travelling in developing countries, I guess that I am more aware of how lucky we are.
With 900 million people not having enough money to access to clean drinking water, let alone access to basic medical care (J Braithwaite, date unknown) such as GPs and midwives shows how people in the developing world have to struggle to visit a doctor or vaccinate their children.
The price of medication doesn't help either. Many of the medications available to these people are patented by for-profit companies in the West which makes them more expensive and out of reach for most people living under 2.8 million living under two dollars a day and the millions more living just above that.
I think those in Western Australia are incredibly fortunate to be able to access a hospital system where so much is provided for.
For example, three meals a day are guaranteed to be served; there is a ready supply of clean bed linen; rooms get cleaned everyday; there are physios, occupational therapists, social workers all trying to get patents ready to go home.
There are even welfare assistants to help patients and their families access government benefits (unheard of in developing countries) if you need it as well as contact utility companies if you are in hospital for longer than expected and need help to rearrange payment
You want to see a Chaplain for spiritual support? One will come to see you without questions, fees or charges.
Hardly sounds like a third world system to me but one that we have access to.Working in a hospital in a large Australian city after travelling in developing countries, I guess that I am more aware of how lucky we are.
Here
in Australia we have such a great healthcare system and while it may not be
perfect 100% of the time, we are so lucky that it is so much better than much
of the developing world. The proof of standard of the Australian hospital
system is this campaign by the Australian Nurses’ Federation against a parking
tax and it is a shame that it is not more appreciated.
Links.
Anthony Kwaku Amoah. 16 April 2012. The plight of Ghana’s health posts. http://www.ghanaweb.com/GhanaHomePage/NewsArchive/artikel.php?ID=235997. Accessed
15 September 2012
http://www.7billion.unsw.edu.au/health-systems.html. Accessed
20 September 2012.
Emma
Pearson. September 15 2009. Congo’s
crippled healthcare. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/e376ef0e-a1f3-11de-81a6-00144feabdc0.html#axzz26X0i4ADu. Accessed
15 September 2012.